Saturday, 15 August 2009

Five Great.... Drugstore Mascaras.

Hmmm... Mascara - such a divisive subject in the beauty world. There is definitely a place in my heart for high end mascara (I will always love YSL Faux Cils dearly - it was the first one I ever tried that made me realise the power of a fluttering lash!), and yet given the fact that macara has to be replaced so regularly for hygiene reasons, it makes sense to make the most of drugstore gems too!

So my current fave drugstore mascara's, in no particular order (that would be impossible! I usually have about three on the go anyway!)....

Rimmel Sexy Curves
This one seems to be something of a "marmite" mascara (you either love it or you hate it...). I personally love it - gives volumised long fluttery lashes and builds well. Some people find the wand too floppy and flexible, but personally I've never had this issue. The bizarrely shaped wand works well to get product onto the lashes, as well as lengthening and building volume. Can clump if you use tonnes of coats, but some people like that too.

Max Factor False Lash Effect

This is marketed as Covergirl LashBlast in the US, and is apparently a best seller over there - a status which it fully deserves in my humble opinion. This has a MASSIVE applicator - one unlike any I've seen before. Basically a large barrelled plastic cone with teeth.... The product itself is also a great formulation - not too thick, not too thin, so it dries quick enough not to smudge, but slow enough to allow you to build your coats up. For me, this gives lovely long, thick and dramatic looking lashes. A fellow makeup addict at work, regularly asks me what mascara I'm wearing when I have this on...
Maybelline Colossal Volume
First off, lets talk about the packaging - I hate it! But this just proves you should never judge a book by its cover... and I suppose it makes it easy to find! This is great for building drama in a flash. I actually recieved this at a blogger event, and possibly would never have picked it up if I hadn't (due to the radioactive packaging), and hence I tried it with some trepidation. However
I was surprised - builds extremely thick lashes with little clumping - this is a great one for a smoky eye, as it gives very thick and intense black lashes.
Barry M 3-in-1 Mascara
Again, I recived this at a blogger event, and I have to say, the makeup snob in me really expected this to be absolute rubbish. One of those occasions where I am so so pleased to be proved totally and utterly wrong. In short - this product costs less than a fiver, promises to curl, lengthen and volumise, and it actually lives up to those claims completely. If you haven't tried this one, I urge you to get to your nearest Barry M counter and be amazed.
Max Factor 2000 Calorie
This is one of those mascara's I keep going back to over and over - like a pair of comfortable shoes, I know exactly where I stand with this one. Gives reliable results and never lets me down. An oldie but a goodie. Coats lashes with minimal clumping and always looks great. A coat or two is great for the day, but extra coats can be added for nocturnal activities!
It has to be said though, for every great drugstore mascara out there, there are some absolute humdingers... some of my most recent let-downs include;
L'oreal Telescopic Explosion - Its difficult to express how much I dislike this mascara, but if you want to spend about 15 minutes faffing about with an applicator that looks like a torture impliment getting the outer corner lashes to look great, only to move towards the inner lashes and have the useless wand clump the outer lashes, then this will be perfect for you. Gawd I hate this one - did not work for me in any way shape or form.
Maybelline Lash Stiletto - Made big promises of long glossy lashes, and failed to deliver on either front. I just found this very average.
L'Oreal Volume Collagen - Looked so promising - huge brush and promises of long volumised fluttery boy-bait style lashes. Achieved this for the first use, however dried up within about ten minutes of opening the tube and promptly clumped horrendously on each following application. Currently trying out the "plus" version to see if it is more successful... will keep you posted!
Any other recommendations? I don't like to miss out on good lashes!
MizzWorthy xxx

17 comments:

Tali said...

Lash stiletto- the biggest let down EVER!!!! I love the maybeline volume one.. i can never remember its name! And yes..good old 2000 calorie is amazing. Cant belive max factor is closing down :(

Glitterish Allsorts said...

I agree with the lasy stiletto point, what on earth happened there?! At first I thought maybe it just didn't work for me but there seems to be a consensus online that is is a big let down.

Am going to try the Barry M one now. Fingers crossed! :)

Daisy said...

I really want to try the Rimmel Sexy Curves mascara- Pixiwoo always use it in their vids so it must be good!

Fab post :)
xx

A~MAKEUP~TALE said...

2000 calorie definitely an oldie but a goodie! & you're spot on with the telescopic explosion it's the biggest gimmick in opinion...

Rupa'sMakeupDiary said...

Hi! I know you love Illamasqua so thought i'd let you know about a great offer i just found out about. if you subscribe to elle magazine this month you get a free Illamasqua blusher and lipgloss!! I've done a blog post about it, check it out:

http://rupasmakeupdiary.blogspot.com/2009/08/subscribe-to-elle-magazine-for-free.html

Cat said...

Jen I couldn't agree with this post more. Right now I am rocking the maybelline colossal volume, love it :-)

xx

BrionyLou said...

Great post :)

I'm so glad its not just me that can't get on with lash stiletto - one of my besties sings its praises, which I can't get my head around!! I adore Colossal and I even quite like the packaging (might be something to do with being blind as a bat without my contacts and it being easy to find!)

xxx

Witoxicity said...

Thanks for this review. I love Rimmel Sexy Curves too. It enhances my lashes and yet, they still look quite natural. I like that. I'm also a fan of Maybelline's VolumExpress. It's great for building up volume. :)

Helen said...

Tali's comment just made me nearly drop my laptop. Max Factor is closing down? This is the worst news I have had all month (ok maybe dramatic but hey...)

What the hell am I going to do without my trusty Masterpiece Max? Thank god I have you to bring me other recommendations. Still, time to start stockpiling the Masterpiece I think!

And to think I almost bought a Lancome Hypnose today but put it back as I'm on a no-buy!

Helen said...

PS I meant to say thankyou SO much for my St Moritz! it arrived safe and sound on Thursday and I can't wait to try it out!

mizzworthy said...

@Tali - boo to lash stiletto - yay to old favourites!

@GlitterishAllsorts - Barry M is fab - let me know how you get on xxx

@Daisy - you'll either love it or hate it!

@UnicornSmile - Telescopic explosion is truly awful, but we do love a bit of 2000 calorie!

@Rupa - thanks so much for letting me know xxx

@Cat - Its so much better than I thought it would be!

@Briony - this is true, lol, you def can't miss that neon packaging!

@Witoxicity - oooh, thanks for the reccomendation - will look out for that one x

mizzworthy said...

@Helen - I heard it was just shutting down in the USA to allow more focus on covergirl over there? Glad you got your tan xxx

Unknown said...

I know is a strange thing but in mascaras I only used high end ones, Chanel, YSL and others. well I tried some drugstore as a teenager but don't remember...
What a snob I am!!!!
Serious, they work for me and last me a long time, never understand people that need a new one every 3 weeks or 6 weeks, for me they last 5 to 6 months.
But was a very interesthing review because i've been thinking about try others and this post was great as a start :)

Katie said...

Ha ha, I hated the Lashblast. I think you either love it or hate it. I hated the big wand. It gave me clumps on the first swipe and I managed to poke (and tear!) my contact lens. I'm severely allergic to Maybelline \.

My favorite mascara is actually a tie between Almay Nourishing Triple Effect mascara in black and Almay Nourishing Volume mascara. The former likes to clump on a third coat but I love both. They don't irritate my super-sensitive skin and eyes and they nourish my lashes. It also helps that even the non-waterproof Nourishing Triple Effect is waterproof yet easy to remove. I've cried for three straight hours with the mascara on and there wasn't one smudge or flake. The stuff is like Krazy Glue.

Lipglossiping said...

Fab post, love most of these and have just bought the BarryM one on your recommendation. Dunno why, I got a flippin drawer of mascaras all sitting unopened - I need help. Thanks for such a great read Jen!

Music said...

So far my HG mascara is Chanel Exceptionnel. In a way I regretted ever trying it coz now I can't go back to other cheaper brands. :(

mizzworthy said...

@Gabriela - I used to be like that too, with YSL faul cils - I used to get a tube for my birthday and one for christmas, but then I guess I just felt like changing things up a bit... I still have a place in my heart for high end though!

@Kate - Mascara is soooo divisive lol - Its funny how what suits one person well, is hell for someone else! Will look out for the Almay x

@Lipglossiping - Oooh, I hope you like it! Let me know how you geton with it!

@Music - I know a LOT of people LOVE that one!